The FDA recently rejected the use of MDMA-assisted therapy for PTSD, citing concerns about safety and efficacy. This decision has prompted other psychedelic companies to refine their strategies, emphasizing more rigorous clinical trials and safety protocols. What once seemed like a clear path to mainstream acceptance for psychedelics, is now once again, fraught with legal uncertainty. However, despite these setbacks, the underground psychedelic community continues to thrive, providing access to transformative therapies and increasing the acceptance of mind-altering experiences, both therapeutic and recreational. The genie is out of the bottle, and the underground shows no signs of slowing down.
Historical Insights and Lessons
The parallels between the current underground psychedelic practices and the Prohibition era in the United States (1920-1933) are striking. The ban on alcohol led to a high demand for illicit beverages, fueling the rise of speakeasies and bootlegging operations. Similarly, the illegal status of psychedelics has generated a robust underground market, where individuals seek out these substances for both therapeutic and recreational purposes.
Research shows that when legal avenues are restricted, demand often shifts to unregulated sources, leading to increased underground activity. For example, as of now, over 150 plant medicine retreats are listed on platforms like Retreat Guru, offering ayahuasca, psilocybin, and San Pedro ceremonies. These retreats are available not only in countries where regulatory frameworks permit access to plant medicines but also in regions where the legal status is still uncertain.
Both the Prohibition and modern psychedelic movements fostered communities dedicated to using prohibited substances. During Prohibition, jazz clubs and speakeasies became cultural hubs that encouraged a vibrant nightlife. In today’s psychedelic scene, the dream of abstinence from mind-altering substances—once championed during the Nixon era—is long gone. At multi-day music and art-centered festivals, communities are forming around harm reduction, emotional support, and psychedelic education.
Filling the Gaps Left by Regulation
Due to the underground nature of these communities, participants face risks that arise from unregulated environments. Organizations like The Fireside Project and Zendo Project emerged to care for those experiencing overwhelming emotions or difficult psychedelic experiences. These organizations aim to create a safer space for users, effectively filling the gap left by regulatory bodies. If psychedelics were legalized and regulated, services could be in place to de-escalate psychedelic crises, prevent drug poisonings, and ensure a safer supply.
Instead, we rely on volunteer-driven organizations like DanceSafe, which has provided testing services, education on safe practices, and peer support since 1998. These grassroots efforts continue to play a vital role in the safety and sustainability of the psychedelic movement
Innovation and Adaptation
The lack of legal access to alcohol led to innovative brewing and distilling techniques among underground producers, as well as new social rituals and cultural practices surrounding drinking. This innovation parallels the creative approaches that emerged in response to Prohibition, reflecting the adaptability of those seeking to engage with restricted substances. in our current psychedelic landscape, drugs are being used for healing, whether the FDA deems them safe or not.
The absence of formal regulation has encouraged practitioners to explore diverse therapeutic modalities and integration practices. These include, but are not limited to, cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), somatic therapy, mindfulness and meditation, art and expressive therapies, breathwork, and neurofeedback. Would this experimentation be possible if there were tighter regulations on psychedelic-assisted therapies? That remains to be seen. Innovation and adaptation are essential right now; the possibilities are vast because there isn’t one "accepted" or "prescribed" way to work with psychedelics. Yes, there are safety practices, and a growing "common knowledge" around set and setting, but the boundaries of what psychedelics can achieve are still being mapped.
This innovation is also transforming the availability of psychedelic products, including packaging and delivery methods. We’re witnessing a surge in diverse offerings such as pre-measured microdoses of psilocybin, psilocybin-infused chocolates and gummies, tinctures made from ayahuasca, and vape pens of DMT. Adjacent plant medicines like Kanna, Kratom, and Hapé have also entered the market. Companies that mass-produce psychedelics are prioritizing innovation in packaging, investing in branding and aesthetics as seriously as they do in the efficacy of their products. The days of sketchy back-alley transactions for shrooms—where dosage and potency were often questionable—are long gone. While platforms like Instagram may serve as a modern "digital back alley" for these transactions, they are no longer the only option.
Today, consumers have access to a wide range of well-packaged, pre-measured doses with clear ingredient labels from reputable companies catering to the psychedelic market. This shift reflects a growing acceptance and understanding of psychedelics, fostering a more responsible culture around their use.
The use of technology in the psychedelic space is also noteworthy. Digital platforms that offer guided experiences or integration support are emerging. Some companies provide virtual therapy sessions or integration circles via apps, allowing users to process their experiences in real-time with professionals. This integration of technology not only supports safety but also enhances the therapeutic outcomes of psychedelic-assisted therapy participants. Once again, technology and community are stepping in where institutions have failed to ensure safety. Innovation is the adaptation resulting from prohibition, and it’s the only path forward.
As contemporary societies grapple with systemic and infrastructural failures in addressing mental health and addiction, there is a growing movement to revive the traditional uses of psychedelics as practiced by Indigenous cultures. Indeed, psychedelic harm reduction communities—whether intentional or not—pay homage to Indigenous ceremonial contexts, emphasizing the importance of set, setting, and community support. Indigenous practices highlight the communal aspects of psychedelic experiences, standing in contrast to the often individualistic and recreational use seen in current contexts. This resurgence of ancestral knowledge is not a nostalgic return to the past; it serves as a foundation for creating a sustainable and respectful framework for psychedelic use today.
What is particularly intriguing—and a sign of the flourishing psychedelic space—is the increasing incorporation of substances without Indigenous precedents, such as MDMA and ketamine, into group ceremonies. Instead of limiting these practices to the traditional "medical model" within the confines of a therapist's office, ritualistic approaches are evolving to facilitate healing for a broader audience with these synthetic compounds.
This shift indicates a significant cultural transformation in how we perceive and utilize these substances. MDMA, (most commonly thought of as a substance apt for raves) is again being used for its therapeutic effects and is being integrated into communal settings, fostering connection and emotional support. Similarly, ketamine is being used in group ceremonies, offering a shared experience that contrasts with its typical "off label use" at ketamine clinics.
These adaptations not only expand access to healing but also challenge conventional therapeutic frameworks, creating spaces that honor the communal and transformative potential of psychedelics. As these practices gain traction, they reflect a growing understanding of the value of shared journeys in the healing process.
Cultural Resilience and Identity
Both the Prohibition and current psychedelic movements have fostered a countercultural identity that challenges societal norms. The underground alcohol scene was associated with rebellion, artistic expression, and a refusal to conform. Similarly, today’s psychedelic communities often embrace personal exploration and healing, resisting the stigma associated with their use. This cultural resilience helps maintain a vibrant underground, despite legal obstacles.
The failure of Prohibition to eliminate alcohol consumption led to the recognition that regulation, rather than criminalization, might be a more effective approach. This historical lesson is echoed in the current debate around psychedelics, where advocates argue that legal regulation, education, and harm reduction could be more beneficial than outright bans. Just as the end of Prohibition led to a safer, regulated alcohol market, a similar approach could enhance the safety and accessibility of psychedelics.
David Nutt's 2010 study, published in The Lancet, ranked alcohol as the most harmful drug overall when considering both its individual and societal effects. Using a multicriteria decision analysis (MCDA), the study assessed 20 drugs across 16 criteria, including physical harm, psychological harm, and societal impact. Alcohol received the highest harm score (72), followed by heroin (55) and crack cocaine (54).
Nutt highlighted how alcohol, despite being legal, causes more widespread harm than many illegal drugs due to its high societal costs, including crime, family breakdown, and healthcare burdens. This study challenges current drug classification systems, which often fail to reflect the true harms associated with substances like alcohol.
The irony is striking: the most harmful substance (alcohol) is also the most widely available and deeply ingrained in our culture. Yet, there’s a silver lining—if something as damaging as alcohol can achieve such cultural prevalence, then so too can psychedelics. As psychonauts, we face the responsibility of ensuring that growing psychedelic regulation does not lead to a superficial "normalization."
With the rapid expansion of psychedelic culture, it’s essential to be mindful participants and stewards of these substances. This means creating not only safe products and communities but also systems that prioritize the care of the most vulnerable, ensuring that safety, education, and harm reduction remain at the forefront of this evolving landscape.
Comments